- Published13 minutes ago
BBC Sport Scotland's Tom English has been answering some of your Scottish rugby questions as Gregor Townsend's team prepare to face Japan at Murrayfield on Saturday.
Colin asked:How long are we going to put up with Gregor Townsend? After nine years in charge we finish middle of the road every year. It's deja vu. With this squad of players we should be doing better.
Tom answered:Put up with? That's a bit disrespectful. I get the frustration around Scotland not being able to make a big breakthrough, and at times I have myself questioned if it might be better if Townsend moved on. But he has taken Scotland forward. Not as forward as everybody would like, of course.
Maybe the reason why Scotland can't win a tournament is because, even though they are a good team, too many other teams are better, have better players in the starting line-up and better players coming off the bench. Thats the harsh reality, I'm afraid.
Townsend will be leaving after the World Cup, so we'll see then if another coach - Franco Smith? Clark Laidlaw? - can get more out of these players. Test rugby is very, very different to club rugby, but we live in hope somebody can take them to the next level.
Andrew asked: It seems Scotland have swapped gameplans with England and now solely rely on kicking the ball away at all times. What has happened to Scotland's attacking flair?
Tom answered:It's still there. First half against the All Blacks we saw plenty from the attack, but not enough lethal execution. Second half was dismal. They lost the forward battle, lost their discipline and lost any chance they had of putting up a fight. It was grim.
Last Sunday, much was made of the conditions. Too much, as far as I'm concerned. It wasn't a monsoon. The ball was wet at times but look at the Wallaby attack in the last few minutes. They scored one brilliant try and were close to scoring another in the last play.
I never bought the line about the conditions making it really hard to play rugby, but Scotland came out with an ultra-conservative gameplan and it was really disappointing. One line break is not good enough.
Fair play, they won the game. Winning is all that matters. But I'm sure we'll see plenty from the attack against Japan. By the way, the England attack isn't kicking so much now. They have X factor all over the place in that backline.
Highlights: Scotland 15-12 Australia
Bill asked:England look much improved. France have just beaten the world champions. Ireland continue to be great. And now Wales beat the All Blacks. Scotland have gone nowhere. Are we to prepare ourselves for a horrible Six Nations and standard group-stage exit at the World Cup?
Tom answered.Nice cheery one. France and Ireland are better than Scotland, even though Scotland beat France last season. France have way more depth and world class. Ireland just have that magic spell over Scotland that has lasted for 12 Tests in a row. They play on Friday night in the Six Nations. I can see it being close.
England are improving, they have a huge number of players. Scotland's record against them is exceptional, but England will be favourites, especially if they continue to get their act together.
No guarantees there, but they have the player depth to be miles better than they've shown in recent years. Wales could be back. We'll wait and see.
I can't agree Scotland have gone nowhere. They beat England, France and Wales last season. They beat Argentina away and Australia at home. That's not exactly 'nowhere'.
They have to end this Irish curse and it probably has to happen in the Six Nations. They need to get that monkey off their back before they meet again at the World Cup. Beating Ireland could unlock some really good things in this Scotland team.
The winner of that Scotland/Ireland group has a very decent chance of doing something special because the heaviest hitters are in the other half of the draw.